Shmini - Understanding Tum'ah/Impurity
03/21/2014 07:47:23 PM
Author | |
Date Added |
The need to call the audible was due to the passing of Dodo, our pet parakeet for the past eight years. I am not writing about this looking for sympathy. In fact, I am not mourning at all; mourning is truly reserved for the loss of human life. This is not to say that someone who loses a pet, especially a pet that they had for a long time and was special to them, should not be upset or sad. Being upset and sad are emotions which are acceptable when a pet dies. In fact, I discussed the halachik ramifications and issues regarding the reciting of a blessing upon hearing bad news and whether or not there is room within halacha to recite it or not. Sure I miss the bird..........but only as a bird. This essay is meant for the adult reader, but let it be known and understood that when family pets die, children need to cope and grieve through a process but do not mourn.
In this week's Parsha Shmini the Torah states the kinds of animals that we as Jews are permitted to eat and those that we may not. The Torah does not use the word 'kosher' but rather chooses the words 'tahor' and 'tamei' - pure and impure - with regard to spirituality. Tumah and Taharah is a very difficult subject for people to grasp because it is foreign to us and is completely spiritual. Having discussed the concept of impurity and purity before, I would rather focus on an element other than the spiritual side: the void that is felt when something once alive is no longer alive.
The Torah states in Vayikra 11:2 "Dabru El B'Nai YisraelLaymor, Zos HaChaya Asher Tochlu Mikal HaBeheima Asher Al HaAretz": "Speak to the Children of Israel, saying: 'These are the life forms that you may eat from among all the animals that are upon the earth". God chooses the word 'HaChaya' - the life forms. Rashi explains the word chaya is related to the word chaim, life. The Rabbis taught that live animals do not receive or accept spiritual impurity known as Tumah. Even when it comes to human beings, gentiles do not become impure according to the Torah. The only living creatures that are susceptible to becoming Tamei are Jews. This is due to the already highly spiritual forces which exist within the Jewish body. These forces need to keep themselves as pure as possible at all times. The greater or higher spiritual being requires more limitation and protection from Tumah. This is why a Kohein has further restrictions on becoming defiled. Tumah separates us from Hashem. Kedusha brings us closer to God while Tumah, spiritual impurities, push us further away from God.
In Jewish law the more something is whole and complete the greater possibility there is for it to become impure. If a person has a vessel which is incomplete, it is not susceptible to becoming Tamei. Once it's complete, however, it is susceptible. A fruit that is still attached to the tree is not susceptible, but once it is completely ripe and falls from the tree it can become Tamei.
Even though the laws of Tumah and Tahara are limited today in the sense that we cannot become completely pure without the Beis Hamikdash, we still try to abstain from 'becoming Tamei/impure'. Laws which specifically apply to Kohanim restrict them from entering a cemetery. Similarly, everyone else is required to wash their hands upon coming into contact with a corpse and also when leaving a cemetery.
There is no Tumah/impurity associated with a dead parakeet. It is not a 'Sheretz' - a very specific type of rodent or lizard that the Torah lists which is highly toxic as far as Tumah is concerned. Nevertheless, the change in status from being alive, where there is definitely no impurity, to ceasing to live contains an air of impurity.
The word 'life' to me always means hope while the word 'death' means there is no hope. Previously, when I entered my home and heard a bird chirping or flying around, the beauty of life and all it represents was evident. Dodo's chirping was life and represented its own form of a living entity and hope. This week when I walked into the house there was a sense of death. It was totally quiet: no chirping, no wings flapping, no noise. There wasn't a halachik Tumah but there was disconnect from life. Our objective as long as we are alive is to be as connected to Hashem as possible. Once we die we longer are connected to Hashem in this world. There will be a different kind of relationship between the soul and Hashem in the next world, but that is spiritual to spiritual. The relationship in this world is unique insofar as it is a physical-to- -spiritual network.
The lesson that I've come to glean from this episode is that there has been a potential increase in impurity due to the death of a living creature. Therefore we must combat that potential and increase the level of holiness and spirituality through learning and performing Mitzvos. The message of death indicates the separating and cessation of life, which is our intimate connection to Hashem. We must do whatever we can to re-attach and make that connection stronger; strengthening that relationship we have to our Maker.
Ah Gut Shabbos
Rabbi Avraham Bogopulsky
Fri, September 19 2025
26 Elul 5785
Click the button below to see the Weekly for Sept. 19-20!
General Davening Schedule
Week of 9/21 and beyond:
Selichos:
Sunday: 7:30am
Monday (Erev Rosh Hashanah): 5:30pm
Thursday (Fast of Gedalia): 5:30am
Friday: 5:45am
Shacharis:
Sunday: 8:00am followed by learning and refreshments
Monday (Shacharis Hataras Nedarim): 7:15am
Tuesday-Wednesday: 7:45am
Thursday-Friday: 6:15am
Daily Mincha/Maariv:
per Shkiah (~20 minutes before Sunset):
Sunday-Monday: 6:30pm
Tuesday (Rosh Hashanah/Tashlich): 6:20pm
Wednesday (Rosh Hashanah): 6:15pm
Thursday (Fast of Gedalia): 6:10pm
Torah Tidbits with Rabbi Frankel: 5 minutes before minyan, Sunday and Thursday this week
Shabbos:
Shacharis: 8:45am
Mincha: 6:05pm
Maariv: 7:21pm
*Please view The Weekly link above for Afternoon times and/or special davening times.

Welcome in the sweet New Year with us!
Rosh Hashanah Dinner
a festive Gathering
Monday, September 22nd
Following Services
We love our visitors!
Upcoming Events







Please sign up to secure your spot!
-
Monday ,
SepSeptember 22 , 2025
Monday, Sep 22nd (All day)
Rosh Hashanah Schedule 7:45-8:25 Pesukei Dezimra 8:25-9:40 Hamelech/Shachris 9:40-10:15 Krias HaTorah 10:15-10:45 Kiddush 10:45-11:00 Drasha 11:00-11:15 Shofar 11:15 Mussaf -
Monday ,
SepSeptember 22 , 2025
Monday, Sep 22nd 8:10p to 10:30p
-
Thursday ,
OctOctober 2 , 2025
Thursday, Oct 2nd 9:00a to 3:00p
-
Thursday ,
OctOctober 2 , 2025
Thursday, Oct 2nd 7:10p to 9:00p
RSVP by registering below! Please specify no. of adults and children attending in your party.
The College Area Eruv, Inc. informed us:
As of 5 PM PDT, Sep. 19, 2025
"Eruv is Up and Operational"
Please check the website weekly for updates.
🚨 Eruv Funds are Critically Low! 🚨
Your donations help defray the cost of upkeep. The College Area Eruv, Inc. Accepts donations by check only.
Find out more!Zmanim for San Diego
Alos Hashachar | 5:21am |
Earliest Tallis | 5:50am |
Netz (Sunrise) | 6:34am |
Latest Shema | 9:38am |
Zman Tefillah | 10:39am |
Chatzos (Midday) | 12:42pm |
Mincha Gedola | 1:12pm |
Mincha Ketana | 4:16pm |
Plag HaMincha | 5:33pm |
Candle Lighting | 6:33pm |
Shkiah (Sunset) | 6:51pm |
Tzais Hakochavim | 7:26pm |
More >> |
Sign up For or manage Your Email Subscriptions

- HOME |
- Donate
- | CONTACT US
Privacy Settings | Privacy Policy | Member Terms
©2025 All rights reserved. Find out more about ShulCloud